BLOG 4 (egg drop challenge)
Hi everyone! Welcome back to my blog! 😋😮💨
This week I will be talking about something very interesting that I have been working on over the past few weeks. (drumrolls please hahha 😭)
I have been 3D printing a product for the egg drop challenge! During this practical we were tasked to 3D print a product that would contain a quail egg that has to be dropped from a height of 2 metres without cracking.
“WHAAAT how is that possible?” were my exact thoughts when I got to know about this practical. Firstly, I had NOT 3D printed anything in my life. The closest I have gotten to navigating something that is 3D printing related was during the CADD lesson we had last term, where we got to learn more about the basic functions of fusion 360. Printing a 3D product and merely navigating the functions of a software were TWO DIFFERENT THINGS.
However as much as this practical appeared daunting, it was also going to be a learning experience for me. I would get to print my very own 3D product alongside my group mate, Kerri! I’m glad I got to tackle this challenge with one of my good friends hehe 😌
To breakdown this blog, some things I will be talking about includes:
- Ideation Process (initial and final)
- Initial Design (failed)
- Final design (success)
- Fusion 360 navigation for initial and final design
- Cura (slicing process)
- 3D printing process
- Reflection/summary
Ideation Process (initial design)
The internet was a crucial tool in our ideation process as we got to discover different designs that other people have created during their egg drop challenge. However theirs were slightly different since they could use materials that were not 3D printed to create their product. However for this practical, we were expected to only use 3D printed parts in our product.
Our first design was inspired by one of the designs that was in the link provided in Brightspace. We took inspiration from the diamond design (the one circled in blue).
However, we decided that making a diamond on Fusion 360 and 3D Printing one would be
too time consuming. Therefore, we opted to turning our product into a hexagon shaped product instead. Thus we proceeded to make 2 hexagon shaped pieces (base and cap).
When pondering on how to connect the base and the cap of the 3D print, we were inspired by Lego models. Lego models have unique studs on them which enables them to be strong interlocking joints between 2 pieces. We wanted our model to be like such, so that the egg is safely interlocked between the 2 pieces and there would be minimal movement to the egg. This way the egg won’t crack easily when dropped either!
Here is a picture of our initial sketch for your viewing:
We initially wanted to include threading on the outer part of the hexagon to make it more aesthetically pleasing because it will look like a “bolt and nut” inspired design. However after doing some trial and error on fusion 360, we realised that threading can only be included for cylinders.
Here is our finalised sketch that we used to create our design on fusion :
Now let’s move onto the FUN part where we get to convert the above shown sketch into a design on fusion 360!
Fusion 360 (initial design)
As mentioned above, our hexagonal product consists of 2 parts (a base and a cap):
Process of Base:
1. To make the hexagon, click on create sketch then click on the ‘create’ → ‘polygon’ → ‘edge polygon’
2. Specify our dimensions with the following: 50 mm for the length of each side and 6 sides of the polygon.
3. After that click ‘E’ on the keyboard and extrude the drawing by 35mm.
4. To create the leg like sockets, click on the circle (top right) → then key in the diameter of the circle to be 5mm for all 6 sockets. This will be the result.
5. After that extrude the 6 holes (same step 3) by 20mm for all.
This will be the final result :
6. To create the indent in the middle of the surface of the egg, plot a line from the centre extension rods. Click on the top left (blue circle) and make sure that the line is in construction. After that go to create → point to plot the midpoint of the line (triangle of the line).
7. From there, create another circle with a diameter of 30mm.
8. Right click on the line and click on the option ‘hole’.
9. Ensure that the dimensions of the hole is 40mm wide and 15mm deep.
10. This will be the final result
Since we're now done with making the base of our hexagonal product, we will move onto making the cap of the product.
Process of Cap:
1. Repeat step 1-5 for the cap as the dimensions are the same.
2. Right click on the line and click the ‘hole’ option and fill in the following data.
3. Create a circle with a diameter of 20mm at the centre by clicking on the circle at the top right.
4. Right click on the line again and click on the ‘hole’ option.
5. Select the following dimensions: depth of 17mm and 20 mm diameter.
6. This is the result! (although in this picture, the extruded distance is 60mm all the other dimensions are the same)
TADA!! 🤓 With that, we brought our imagination to life with the help of Autodesk Fusion 360. Then, we proceeded to the workshop to 3D print our design. However, after we printed the model, we discovered that both the base and cap did not fit as the holes were smaller due to the fact that we over specified the dimensions of the connection points. This was mainly due to printing errors that could have occurred during printing. Since this was our first time 3D printing, we were not aware of the consequences that over specifying the dimensions might also lead to the failure of the print.
Since some holes were not aligned properly when we tried to interlock the base and cap together, this led to the overall failure of the product.
This made us feel slightly frustrated because we had already gone through days of 3D printing and now our product had failed on us :( I think it is human nature to feel defeated and frustrated at this point of time but thankfully we picked ourselves up and decided to take a chance of creating a COMPLETELY NEW DEISGN FROM SCRATCH. 🥲🥲
Ideation process (final design)
After 3D printing our first design, we were more confident in navigating fusion 360 and proceeded to brainstorm on making a better product, while taking into account the previous errors we made with our initial design. In a way, the first design didn’t go to waste because we got to learn from our mistakes!
For our next design, we were going to make a cube like structure that resembles a "pillow-like" body so it would be the perfect cushion for our egg (geddit? 🤓).
For better visualisation, here is a sketch of the product:
Using this sketch, we turned our sketch into a 3D model on fusion 360 :-)
Fusion 360 (final design)
Our final design consisted of 3 different parts (a lid, a body and rods x4)
To create the body:
1. Go to create form on the top left corner
2. Then, go to the "box" option.
3. Specify all the dimensions to be 60mm meaning that it would be 60mm x 60mm x 60mm
4. Click on finish sketch at the top right hand corner
5. Go to the top of the model then click on create sketch
6. Go to the option circled in blue at the top left and then create the two lines from the corners of the top. This is so that we can find the midpoint of the top to draw the circle to make the hole to place the egg.
7. After that, go to the circle option at the top left corner and create another circle with a diameter of 40mm.
8. After that, right click to make the hole. The dimensions of the hole would be: 45mm wide and 30 mm deep.
9. This would be the final result
After making the body, we proceeded to make the lid of our model:
- Firstly, create a circle of 33mm diameter which would be the bottom of the cap. To do so, click on the circle at the top left, then key in your value.
2. Extrude it by 4mm
3. After that, repeat step 1 and 2 by making another circle with a diameter of 29 mm and extrude a distance of 6mm.
4. This is how the lid looks like at the end of the process
For our last part (rods x4):
1. Go to create sketch then click on the circle on the top left corner. Then create a circle with a diameter of 5mm.
2. Extrude the rod with a distance of 10mm
3. This is the final result. For our design, we have to make 4 of these.
Now that we have all the parts we need for our final 3D print, let me walk you through how to upload your fusion file onto Cura and go about using the 3D printer.
Cura (splitting process)
- Before printing make sure that the file is saved in the form of a stl.file. Go to document settings, right click, → save as mesh → make sure that the format of the document is :stl (binary) or stl (ASCII) any is fine → click ‘ok’
2. Save your file and then launch Cura.
3. After launching Cura, upload the model that you intend to print and adjust the settings accordingly to ur preference. After that, click on ‘slice’ at the bottom right hand corner, to obtain the estimated time on how long your 3D model may take to print.
4. Save your file onto the thumb drive of the printer you are planning to use and you're all set to print!
5. Take not of the things you have to key in eg. infill density etc (ours is shown in the image above)
3D Printing
5. Then, proceed to insert the STL thumb drive onto the printer and select the file you're intending to print. With that, you're all set to print your model!
(take note that you just allow the machine to warm up a little as there might be filament left in the printer from any previous print)
After setting up the printer, insert the appropriate settings onto the printer.
Our printer settings are as shown below:
(It is crucial to observe your print once in awhile so that it is easier to troubleshoot in the event the print fails. DO also note that you should let the printer cool down before removing the print. Failure to do so might damage the print and pose a hazard to the user.)
6. After printing has been carried out, turn off the printer followed by the heater and the main switch of the printer.
7. If no one is using the printer after you, remember to put the filament back into the dry box and place the filament back into the cabinet.
After many hours our printing our separate parts, we combined our parts together for the drop test. To insert the rods onto the body of the model, we had to drill some holes at a 45 degree angle. The reason behind this placement was that we wanted the rods to absorb any impact pressure that will be exerted onto our 3D product. In simple words, we wanted these rods to be a form of "sacrifice" so that the egg is unharmed after the drop test.
This is our final 3D model:
(front/side view)
(top view)
This is the video of our drop test! (including proving of raw egg)
As you can see from the video above, the egg ALMOST survived the drop test. Although it cracked, I feel that the 3D product indeed saved the egg from major damage. This also tells us that there is always room for improvement :-)
Overall, this practical had taught us many things (both technical stuff and also soft skills). I have learnt the importance of patience and perseverance over the past few weeks. Initially although most of our designs failed, we pushed through to tackle this practical with more enthusiasm each time. Moreover, this practical has taught me more on time management. I feel that we would not have been so stressed if we had started out practical earlier during the holidays, rather than during the last 2 weeks. This way we wouldn't have had to wake up at 5am just to rush to school to secure a printer 😭😭. Nonetheless, we learn more by making mistakes so this experience might be something to look back on whenever we procrastinate on our other tasks in life 😦 Although the last few weeks have been tiring, I am very grateful for this learning experience and I hope to broaden my knowledge on 3D printing further in the future!
Well that's all for this blog guys, hope you enjoyed reading about my experience on the egg drop challenge. See you next time! 😋😋
Comments
Post a Comment