blog 7


Hey everyone! 😌 Welcome back to my last blog for this module. In this blog, I’d be telling y’all about our final chemical product and our journey (CA1+CA2) in creating this product! πŸ€“πŸ€“

To breakdown this blog, here are some parts I will be talking about: 

CA1: 

-       Problem identification 

-       Literature review 

-       SCAMPER

-       Feasibility Analysis 

-       Idea Decision Matrix (COWS) 

CA2: 

-       Operating principles of product

-       Specifications and prototyping 

-       How our product works + sketches (initial and final)


Without any further ado, let’s proceed on with the blog! 🀠

 

Problem identification

Before embarking on our chemical product design journey, Mr Chua had introduced different categories that we could base off our product on. 

 

These were: lack of water, sustainability, global warming, and smart factory. 

 

We were asked to create a chemical product that addresses a problem or issue as mentioned above. A crucial requirement expected of us was to create a product that should be driven and governed by the requirements of the customers or specific industry. Specifically, our product must be one that could tackle the pain points of customers. 

 

If you recall from my previous blogs, I had talked about what pain points are. To recap, pain points are specific problems that are experienced by the user using the product or service. Pain points in extreme cases can cause your user to abandon the product of service they are using. 

 

Through substantial research, we decided to base off our product on the category of sustainability as this was a topic we were passionate on. As a group, it was important for us to create a chemical product that tackled an issue that we truly believed in, as we only wanted to “sell” a product that has meaning to us. We wanted to merge the idea of sustainability and recyclability to create a final product.

 

During research, we realised that although coffee beans had various uses such as being used in clothing apparel, skin care products, as fertilisers, and for consumption, there were still a large amount of coffee grounds being discarded after just ONE USE!


We discovered that approximately 18 million tonnes coffee grounds are actually being discarded after single use per year. This statistic came as a shock to us as we had no idea that there was such a large number of coffee waste being generated yearly! This encouraged us to brainstorm further to create a potential solution for this issue. After surfing through google, we uncovered that coffee beans are actually excellent insect repellents!

 

This inspired our initial idea was to create an environmentally friendly, multi-purpose candle that can be used as both an aroma inducer and an insect repellent. Since this candle was going to be made from used coffee grounds, we managed to come up with an idea that makes use of both sustainability and recyclability!

 

Literature review

Although we had an idea of what we wanted to base off our chemical product on, we did not want to limit ourselves and were still open to any new ideas! 

 

With that we proceeded to do our literature reviews. If you recall, literature reviews are a survey of literature such as books, articles, and other resources that help to address important issues and theories relevant to your research areas. They can be in various forms such as experimental, non-experimental, qualitative and non-qualitative. Ultimately, literature reviews must be of a relevant source and should consist of a supporting and opposing point of view on a topic, as that it doesn’t come off as biased.

 

Here are the topics we based off our literature reviews on:

 

1.     To what extent did coffee grounds affect pests/insects?

2.     Can corn cobs be used as aggregates for cement mix?

3.     Is Xylitol a good substitute for sugar? 

4.     Is charcoal a suitable substitution for bleach as a cleaning solution?

5.     How useful as eggshells as fertilisers?

 

Based on the ideas and concepts we had gained upon research, we picked our initial idea of making use of coffee grounds as insect repellents. Although we picked our initial idea, researching on various topics helped us to expand our knowledge on sustainability and recyclability!

 

SCAMPER process

After carrying out literature reviews to narrow down the topic we wanted to base off our product on, we carried out the SCAMPER process. If you recall, the SCAMPER process is an effective process in developing existing ideas as it helps us to brainstorm further on the mechanics behind the chemical product. This helps us to churn out more variations of ideas for our chemical product! 

 

The SCAMPER process is also broken down as…

 

S: Substitute 

C: Combine 

A: Adapt 

M: Modify

P: Put to another use 

E: Eliminate 

R: Reverse 

 

The minimum requirement was to use at least 3 letters of our SCAMPER to churn out ideas. Our SCAMPER process applied to our initial idea is as follows: 



We decided to push ourselves to use more letters than the minimum requirement and managed to use 6/7 SCAMPER letters! This was definitely beneficial as some of these ideas were not ones that we would have thought of if not for the SCAMPER process. With that, we moved on to carry out the feasibility analysis. 

 

Feasibility Analysis 

Carrying out the feasibility analysis helps us to sieve out unrealistic and unsuitable ideas that do not fit into the common requirement criteria for most chemical products. For this, we used the ideas generated from SCAMPER. Through this analysis, we could check that the ideas were BUDGET friendly, and able to be completed within the given TIMELINE, while also considering its FEASIBILITY. 

 

The feasibility analysis for each SCAMPER idea is as follows:

 









 

By using the ideas that were approved during the feasibility analysis, we carried out the COWS analysis. The acronym “COWS” refers to combine, options, weightage, and score. 

 

The COWS decision matrix is an excellent way of selecting our best and most feasible ideas through weighing them on a scale filled with criteria that is customisable by us. This way, we will be able to choose an idea that feels most important to us and thus gives more meaning to our final product. 

 

Our COWS matrix criteria specification, weightages and scores is as follows: 

 





By doing the COWS decision matrix, we managed to determine the ideas with the highest score. We obtained the same score of 255 for our idea 1 and 4, and this inspired us to combine both these ideas into a better and more sustainable one! 

 

Hence our final idea was to create an environmentally friendly, multi-purpose candle that would be used both as an aroma inducer and an insect repellent. To make this idea more sustainable, we would be using soybean wax as the body of the candle instead of conventional paraffin wax, as soybean wax is non-toxic to the environment. Moreover, the candle container is made from bamboo as bamboo is an eco-friendly and renewable resource. The wick of our candle would be made from organic cotton than regular cotton as organic cotton reduces environmental impact, hence making it very sustainable. 

 

 Specifications and Prototyping

We wanted to create a candle that would be well-loved by all our customers, leading them on to keep restocking on after the candle is finished. Personally, my favourite of candles are from BATH AND BODY WORKS. I’m sure many of you are familiar with this brand. Bath and body works are known for their addictive candle scents as well as the lifespan of their candles. Their candles are relatively on the bigger side, but not too big to the extent where it is no longer compact. Since my group was determined on creating a candle that was both compact and had a long life span (aka burning time), we used the bath and body works candles as a reference when coming up with the dimensions of our product. 

 

This was our initial sketch of our product (CA1): 



  

However when doing our CA2, we realised that we wanted to increase the dimensions of our candle to be bigger in terms of width and height so that a greater volume of soybean wax can be contained and thus ultimately result in longer burning time. 

 

Hence our final sketches with new dimensions is as follows: 



 


After creating the final sketch, we also narrowed down the specifications of our product. The specification table is as follows: 



Reasons for the specifications: 

-       We wanted the bamboo container and soybean wax to be poor conductors of heat so that the candle does not heat up and injure the user when lighted up 

-       We wanted the candle to be compact and lightweight so that it can be easily stored

-       We wanted the candle to have a long lifespan so that it was worth the user’s money 

-       We wanted the candle to have a scent strong enough to fill up a room so that it can diffuse its aroma across the room and also be an efficient insect repellent. 


Operating principles of the candle

The main operating principles of our candle included combustion and heat transfer via conduction, convection, and radiation. During combustion, the organic cotton wick is lighted up due to the presence of heat and oxygen. This provides warmth and light to the surroundings. Heat from the flame is transmitted from the hotter region of the soybean wax to the colder region of wax. This causes the wax body to melt due to conduction and heat is transmitted to the surroundings through radiation as well. When the candle melts, its aroma is being diffused across the room and thus it fulfils its function as both an aroma inducer and an insect repellent. There would also be indirect mass transfer between the body of the candle and the surroundings as the amount of candle decreases over time. 

 

Prototyping 

Firstly, we started off by drawing a circle with a diameter of 80mm (8cm). We made 2 of these circles as we wanted to use one for the top and one for the bottom of the candle. 



 

After this, we cut out a rectangle with a width of 120 mm to represent the height of the candle. 

 

To attach both pieces, we rolled the rectangular piece into the shape of a cylinder. To ease the process of rolling, we cut lines along the cardboard. 



We used glue to attach the rectangular piece to the top and bottom pieces and rolled them up against each other. We created the wick of the candle using cardboard scraps from the body of the candle. 




After which we coloured the top of the candle with a silver marker to represent the soybean wax body. 



With that let us show you our final prototype! 



( to use our product, all you have to do is light up the wick!)

With that, we were done creating the prototype of our chemical product! We have now come to the end of this module πŸ₯². This module has enabled me to express my creativity into different ideas and I am grateful for have gotten this experience! I hope to apply what I have learnt in this module to the following chemical product design modules in the future. 


With that, here’s a picture of my LOVELY group πŸ˜™ Goodbye for now! πŸ˜‹πŸ˜‡



( team serenity ) totally not inspired by my name πŸ€₯


bonus video of jeevan getting a leg cramp during our cardboard prototyping 🀭


Comments